Energy Transition Trackers
Leaders and Laggards in the Low-Carbon Transition
Track Transition Strategies versus Financial Performance
The Idea
The energy transition is reshaping industries and redefining the global economy, particularly the energy sector. For investors, the challenge lies in understanding how transition strategies influence financial performance, whether through traditional hydrocarbons, natural gas as a “bridge fuel,” or emerging clean energy technologies.
At FFI Solutions, we have developed the Transition Trackers to help investors navigate this complexity. These tools assess the financial and strategic positioning of companies along the energy transition spectrum by:
-
Distinguishing between Leaders making ambitious low-carbon investments and Laggards relying on traditional strategies.
-
Tracking the performance of integrated oil majors, exploration and production companies, and clean energy innovators.
-
Using metrics that include climate commitments, emissions targets, low-carbon investments, and sector-specific financial returns.
The Transition Trackers provide a comprehensive lens to evaluate how companies in the energy sector are adapting to the evolving demands of a low-carbon economy, offering insights into both risks and opportunities.
The Transition Trackers
Integrated Oil & Gas
Tracks the financial performance and transition strategies of integrated oil and gas companies, highlighting the relative progress of Leaders investing in low-carbon solutions compared to Laggards prioritizing traditional hydrocarbon businesses.
Integrated Oil & Gas
No Data Found
Q3 2024 Overview
The Integrated Leaders, including BP, Shell, and Total, have set relatively ambitious emissions targets and invested more in renewable energy and clean solutions compared to the Integrated Laggards, including Suncor, Imperial Oil, and Cenovus. The Leaders portfolio underperformed the Laggards, returning 7.5% vs. 8.2% (annualized) since January 2022. This suggests that the market may have rewarded Laggards for prioritizing traditional hydrocarbon businesses over Leaders’ long-term low-carbon investments.
Exploration & Production
Tracks the financial performance of exploration and production companies, contrasting Leaders focused on natural gas as a bridge fuel in the energy transition with Laggards reliant on oil production.
Exploration & Production
No Data Found
Q3 2024 Overview
E&P Leaders outperformed E&P Laggards by 16.1% cumulatively since January 2022. This outperformance likely stems from the Leaders having a higher proportion of their production tilted toward natural gas rather than oil. These companies, including many U.S. independent producers, benefited from better natural gas prices and the U.S. becoming the world’s largest LNG exporter. This performance aligns with the view that natural gas can act as a “bridge fuel” in the energy transition, with a corresponding lower risk of asset stranding compared to oil reserves.
Energy Transition Swap
The Energy Transition Swap is a synthetic instrument that tracks the relative performance of clean energy (QCLN) and traditional energy (XOP) ETFs, offering exposure to the energy transition trend.
Energy Transition Swap
No Data Found
Q3 2024 Overview
During the investment period from 2014 to 2024, XOP’s performance reflected volatility in the oil and gas sector. After suffering losses during the 2020 oil price collapse, it rebounded strongly in the post-pandemic recovery but remained below pre-2015 highs due to subdued long-term crude prices. QCLN experienced a surge in 2020 alongside broader technology stocks, driven by Federal Reserve support, but declined in 2023 as rising interest rates heavily impacted pre-profit clean technology companies. This divergence underscores the distinct market dynamics affecting the two sectors.
Read our full analysis of the Energy Transition Intelligence Trackers:
Methodology
Our trackers analyze companies’ transition strategies and performance through three complementary approaches:
Universe and Data Foundation
- Starting universe: The Carbon Underground Oil & Gas 100 (ranked by emissions embedded in reserves)
- Excludes companies from markets with insufficient shareholder rights or market access
- Data spans 14 key metrics across climate commitments, emissions targets, clean investments, and operational performance
- Quarterly updates to all metrics and rankings
Leaders & Laggards Classification
Integrated Oil & Gas Companies
Evaluates major integrated energy companies on:
- Emissions reduction targets and progress
- Clean energy investment commitments
- Technology development and deployment
- Capital allocation to transition activities
Top third of ranked companies classified as Leaders, bottom third as Laggards
Exploration & Production (E&P) Companies
Assesses independent producers based on:
- Natural gas vs. oil production mix
- Operational efficiency and emissions intensity
- Methane reduction initiatives
- Asset portfolio transition readiness
Top third of ranked companies classified as Leaders, bottom third as Laggards
Energy Transition Swap
Synthetic instrument tracking clean energy vs. traditional energy performance
Structure:
- Long position: First Trust NASDAQ Clean Edge Green Energy Index Fund (QCLN)
- Short position: SPDR S&P Oil & Gas Exploration & Production ETF (XOP)
- Notional size: $1 million with 20% initial margin
- Daily market-to-market valuation
- Margin call trigger at $100,000, true-up to $200,000
QCLN payer obligations:
- Pay gains in QCLN
- Pay losses in XOP
QCLN receiver obligations:
- Pay gains in XOP
- Pay losses in QCLN
The methodology enables investors to:
- Monitor transition progress across different energy subsectors
- Compare company strategies and implementation
- Track relative performance between clean and traditional energy
- Identify emerging trends in the energy transition
Download Our Whitepaper
Energy in Transition: A Framework for Evaluating Strategies and Actions of Oil & Gas Companies
The Value of Transition Intelligence
Data-Driven Insights: Leveraging over 25,000 data points, 50 data fields and 14 key metrics spanning climate commitments to clean investments, our Transition Intelligence platform offers a unique view of the transition plans and actions of the 100 largest oil and gas companies.
Strategic Advantage: Unlike other third-party rankings or benchmarks, the platform enables investors to make informed decisions that reflect their unique view on the nature and pace of the energy transition, and what constitutes the “right” transition strategy.
For investors and asset managers alike, these insights aren’t just data — they’re a roadmap to navigating and capitalizing on the energy transition.
Get In Touch
Curious about how these trends could influence your strategies? Interested in a demo of the Transition Intelligence platform? Want to explore the detailed performance of Leaders and Laggards?
Contact Us: Fill out the form or reach out directly to start the conversation. Let’s explore how you can leverage transition insights for strategic advantage.